Yellow Oyster Po’Boy

By Smallhold

yellow oyster po'boy

Yield: 1 Sandwich
Time: 45 Minutes

Ingredients.

(1/2) 8 oz box of yellow oyster mushrooms
1 cup all-purpose flour
¼ cup cornmeal
1 tbsp baking powder
3 tbsp Creole seasoning
2 large eggs
1 quart vegetable oil, for frying
Salt to taste
1 sub roll, lightly toasted
½ cup shredded iceberg lettuce
1 small tomato, sliced
Dill pickles (optional)
Mayonnaise or remoulade sauce
Salt, to taste
½ lemon, cut into wedges

Directions

Step 01 - Trim off any tough ends of the mushrooms and cut into small clusters. Season the mushrooms with salt and set aside.

Step 02 - In a bowl, whisk together flour, cornmeal, baking soda and Creole seasoning. In a separate bowl, whisk together eggs. Prepare a wire rack inside a rimmed baking sheet.

Step 03 - Working in batches, add mushrooms to flour mixture and toss to evenly coat. Shake off excess flour, transfer to egg mixture, and turn to thoroughly coat. Allow excess batter to drip back into bowl and return to flour mixture. Press gently to help coating adhere. Transfer to prepared wire rack. Repeat dredging process with remaining mushrooms, then set aside.

Step 04 - In a large shallow pan, heat oil over medium-high to 375°F. Carefully add mushrooms to the oil and cook, being careful not to overcrowd them. Give them a flip halfway and fry until golden brown, 4 to 5 minutes. Season with salt to taste. 

 Step 05- For Serving: Open rolls, and spread cut sides with mayonnaise. Divide lettuce, tomatoes, pickle chips, and mushrooms evenly among rolls. Serve immediately.

By: Phoebe Tran

Discover Smallhold's specialty mushrooms. Shop our full selection online or visit us in store.

  • Blue Oyster Mushrooms

    Meaty, umami

    Sturdy, absorbent, and satisfyingly chewy, Blue Oysters can liven up anything from stir fries to pastas. They’re great with eggs in the morning or fried rice at lunch, and their texture and size make them an ideal meat replacement. Saute ‘em, roast ‘em, or grill ‘em—there’s no wrong way to enjoy ‘em.

    blue oyster mushrooms
  • Trumpet Mushrooms

    Buttery, sweet

    Any way you slice it, these Trumpet mushrooms can take the heat. With thick, meaty stems and a pleasantly chewy texture, they can be cut lengthwise and sauteed, or sliced into rounds, scored, and grilled to perfection. They’re delcious on their own, or as a meat substitute in stuffings, pot-pies, and even seafood dishes like scallops. 

  • Lion's Mane Mushrooms

    Nutty, sweet, savory

    These Lion’s Mane mushrooms are as intriguing as they are appetizing. Soft and spongy, they can be shredded, pressed into steaks, or thrown into soup like dumplings. They’re also a great substitute for crab or lobster meat, so just add them to your favorite seafood recipe to get your savory shellfish fix.

    lion's mane mushrooms
  • Oyster Mushroom Pack

    This colorful kit contains our classic Yellow and Blue Oyster mushrooms. One box has all you need to supercharge your stir fry or make a stellar stew.

    mixed oyster mushroom pack
  • Umami Mushroom Pack

    This pack is chock full of rich umami flavors. Add depth to any meal with Shiitakes, and sop up all the extra goodness with some Oysters.

    umami mushroom pack with blue oyster, shiitake and trumpet mushrooms
  • Fancy Mushroom Pack

    A unique combination designed for one-of-a-kind dishes. This pack contains mushrooms we've been custom growing for chefs in Brooklyn, making it a must-try for every Mushroom Head.

    fancy mushroom pack with lion's mane, maitake and trumpet mushrooms